When I was recruiting for consulting, most candidates introduced themselves by talking about their major, their school, and the company where they had worked.
I talked about cows and bears, and it made everyone remember me.
Before business school, I had worked as an operations engineer for a natural gas company in rural Canada. My stories took place in the field, where encounters with animals were part of the job and where I worked alongside people whose lives were completely different from mine.
Those stories gave people something to remember. They also gave me a natural way to explain who I was, what I had learned from moving between very different environments, and why I eventually wanted an MBA and a career in consulting.
I ultimately received offers from McKinsey, BCG, and Bain in the same recruiting cycle.
By the time formal interviews arrived, I already knew which stories made people lean in, which details prompted follow up questions, and how to connect those experiences to the person I wanted to become. I had been testing and refining those stories throughout networking.
That is why consulting fit interview preparation should begin before, or at least alongside, networking.
Most candidates do the opposite. They attend coffee chats and recruiting events first. Then they practice cases. Only near the end do they begin thinking seriously about the fit interview.
That order gives up one of the easiest advantages in consulting recruiting. Reflecting on your experiences early helps you become more memorable during networking, build stronger relationships, and give people a reason to advocate for you when interview invitations are being decided.
This does not mean every networking conversation is a formal interview or that you should force memorized answers into coffee chats. It means you should understand who you are, which stories make you distinctive, and how your experiences connect to consulting before you begin introducing yourself to firms.
Why candidates delay fit preparation
Candidates know that case interviews require specialized preparation, so they start practicing frameworks, exhibits, and math. Fit interviews feel less urgent because the questions sound familiar:
Tell me about yourself.
Why consulting?
Why this firm?
Tell me about a time you led a team.
Tell me about a difficult conflict.
Because the format feels familiar, candidates assume they can prepare later. But the most compelling stories usually come from reflection, not improvisation.
If you wait until the week before the interview, you may remember the most obvious experience on your resume rather than the story that reveals how you think or explains why someone would want you on their team.
Networking conversations are better when you know your own story
Many networking introductions sound almost identical.
“Hi, I am a first year MBA student interested in consulting. Before school, I worked in finance. I would love to learn more about your experience at the firm.”
There is nothing wrong with that introduction. There is also little for the other person to remember. Your goal is not to manufacture an unusual fact. It is to identify the experiences that genuinely shaped you and explain why they matter.
Your best stories improve the questions you ask
It is difficult to ask distinctive networking questions when you have not decided what you are actually trying to learn.
Before business school, I had spent years in oil and gas working mostly with men who were much older than me. I learned a great deal from them, but I also knew that I wanted women leaders and mentors as I entered the next stage of my career.
Instead of asking, “What is the culture like?” I could say:
“I am used to working in a heavily male environment with colleagues who were often much older than me. I learned a lot from that experience, but I also know that I want to learn from more women leaders as I build the next stage of my career. How have mentors from different genders and backgrounds shaped your experience at this firm?”
That question reveals something real about my background and priorities. It also invites the other person to share an experience rather than recite the firm’s culture statement.
If one of your most important stories involves earning trust from a skeptical stakeholder, you might ask:
“A lot of my previous work involved bringing resistant stakeholders along. At what point in a project do junior consultants begin owning those relationships?”
Those questions stand out because they come from something real.
Fit preparation does not only help you answer questions. It helps you ask better ones.
What to prepare before networking begins
You do not need polished answers to every possible fit question. You need a strong foundation.
1. A clear introduction
Prepare a concise explanation of where you have been, what you are doing now, and why consulting is a logical next step.
It should sound like a coherent story, not a tour through every line of your resume.
2. Three or four experiences that reveal something important about you
Choose stories that show different sides of your working style.
You might include an experience where you led through uncertainty, changed someone’s mind, recovered from a setback, navigated conflict, or created impact without formal authority.
Choose stories that reveal your judgment, motivation, and personality, not only an impressive outcome.
3. The moments inside each story that make it memorable
The strongest stories contain specific decisions, tensions, and turning points.
What made the situation difficult? What did you notice that others missed? What choice did you make? What did you learn about yourself?
4. The questions you genuinely want to answer about each firm
Once you understand your own priorities, you can identify what you need to learn from networking.
Perhaps you care about apprenticeship, international staffing, early client exposure, particular industries, or the way teams handle disagreement.
Your questions should help you determine whether the firm fits you, not merely signal that you researched its website.
Use networking to improve your fit answers
Early preparation does not mean the answers are finished.
Networking conversations let you test how you describe your background and interests. Notice which parts prompt follow up questions and which explanations feel long or unclear.
Pay attention to the reaction your stories receive. If someone becomes curious, asks for more detail, or remembers the story later, you have probably found something distinctive.
If a story receives no reaction, that is useful information too. You still have time to tell it differently. Change the setup, sharpen the tension, or make your own decision more visible. If the story continues to fall flat, choose another one.
The first version of a story does not have to be the version you eventually use in an interview. Networking gives you repeated chances to discover which experiences make you stand out and how to tell them well.
You will also learn how people inside each firm describe their work and culture, giving you better information for explaining why that firm appeals to you.
The process should move in both directions:
Reflection improves your networking, and networking improves your interview answers.
By the time interviews begin, you will have discussed the experiences naturally, learned which details resonate, and developed a clearer understanding of why consulting fits your goals.
Do not wait until casing is finished
Case preparation can consume every available hour because the gaps are easy to see. You miss a calculation, struggle with a framework, or receive a weak score, and immediately know what to practice next.
Fit preparation feels less measurable, so candidates postpone it.
But the purpose of fit preparation is not merely to survive a behavioral question. It is to understand what you want the interviewer, and the people you meet throughout recruiting, to remember about you.
The candidates who stand out during networking are not always the people with the most unusual resumes. They are often the people who have reflected enough to explain their choices clearly, share interesting experiences naturally, and ask questions that reveal genuine curiosity.
Do that work before the first coffee chat.
It will make every conversation after it better.
Fit preparation helps people remember who you are. Case practice shows them how you think. Build both before interview day.
Try a case free